By Simon Briggs, Tennis Correspondent, in New York
Dan Evans had the purists purring on Arthur Ashe Stadium as he exchanged highlight-reel winners with world No 1 Carlos Alcaraz.
It was not enough to pull off an upset, but Evans was at least rewarded by the crowd’s appreciation – and by the Sky Sports commentary team’s verdict that this was the match of the tournament to date.
Alcaraz’s 6-2, 6-3, 4-6, 6-3 victory featured many more smiles than you would normally expect from a top-level tennis contest. At times, it felt like exhibition stuff, what with all the dinks, drops, lobs and tweeners on show. That is just the way these two play.
If more of their fellow pros possessed such a complete skill-set – as well as the courage to try out so many different options – then the US Open’s ticket prices would be even more eye-watering than they already are.
Evans had come into this match on the back of career-best results, notably his capture of the ATP 500 event in Washington four weeks ago. But Alcaraz’s extra class was visible from the very first point. Evans sent down a respectable second serve, which Alcaraz biffed back at him with racket-melting power.
Alcaraz had soon wrapped up the opening game with a delightful drop shot, thus showing that – in golfing terms – he has mastered both the long game and the short. A bewildered Evans turned to his back-room team and made a “What am I supposed to do here?” gesture with his hands. He had soon slipped to a 4-1 deficit in just 21 minutes, less than half the time that his close friend Andy Murray had spent contesting the same number of games with Grigor Dimitrov on Thursday.
When Evans pulled off a spectacular full-stretch volley winner to open the sixth game, one fan harrumphed: “That’s the first good shot he’s hit all match.” But the crowd soon warmed to Evans’s whole-hearted effort, which found him applying more and more pressure to the Alcaraz serve as the match went on.
The spirit of the contest was encapsulated by one astonishing rally in the middle of the second set. Alcaraz kept sending up towering lobs, and Evans kept replying with smashes, but in the end had to revert to a delicate backhand pass. Both men grinned at that one, which is another reason why Alcaraz is becoming such a crowd favourite. Almost uniquely among 21st Century champions, he shows evident enjoyment of the game while he is competing, and has a rare playfulness about him on the court.
In an era of relentless baseline grinding, here was a treat for Arthur Ashe ticket-holders. Tennis is a better sport when players move on both the x and y axes, rather than simply shuttling left and right all day long. Between them, Evans and Alcaraz came to the net 117 times in a match that lasted 238 points. The second set ended with another thrilling rally that featured an Alcaraz lob, an Evans “tweener” retrieval and then an Alcaraz drop-volley to seal the game.
Did Alcaraz ease up to drop the third set? Not exactly. This was arguably the best set of tennis that Evans has ever produced. He landed three-quarters of his first serves, and struck just a single unforced error – a backhand volley into the net-tape on set point, with the whole court at his mercy. Evans turned to his locum coach Colin Beecher at that moment, and put his hand on his head in a gesture that transmitted the message: “What have I done?”
To his credit, he regrouped moments later and drew an error from Alcaraz’s forehand return of serve – perhaps the only weak point in the world No 1’s game – to claim his first set against this opponent in three meetings. It did not mean much in the end. Alcaraz lifted his own level to rack up an extraordinary 22 clean winners in the fourth set, many of them from apparently impossible positions. But Evans can still consider this a worthwhile outing because it demonstrated how high his standard of shot-making can go.
“He always wanted to come to the net,” said Alcaraz in his on-court interview. “Good slices, great touch. We play great points that made us smiling. Daniel as well. It’s great to see that on a tennis court. We play to make people happy as well, to make funny [fun] the match.”
Evans’s run to the third round matched his progress here last year, so his ranking – currently No 28 in the world – is unlikely to change much. But British No 1 Cameron Norrie fell in straight sets to the little-known Matteo Arnaldi, an Italian 22-year-old who had only ever won a single match in a major when he pitched up here a week ago.
Norrie will not be happy with this one-sided loss in a match he had been the favourite to win, nor with his tally of 29 unforced errors, including 14 on his normally rock-solid backhand side.