By Jason Burt at Wembley
Martin Odegaard raised the Community Shield, the distinctive handspun sterling silver plate weighing 4.2kg and standing 58cm high, but that was as nothing as to the huge psychological weight that was lifted from Arsenal’s shoulders.
Make no mistake this mattered - for Arsenal. For Manchester City? Maybe less so. After all, City have proven in the recent past that losing the season’s curtain-raiser can mean very little – they were beaten last year by Liverpool and 12 months previously by Leicester City, who are now in the Championship, the year before – but this time it did feel significant.
And for Arsenal and, maybe, also for City, this result is a sign that Arteta’s side finally have the mentality to compete against the champions and close that gap even further.
Having been allowed to buy Gabriel Jesus and Oleksandr Zinchenko from City last year, Arsenal were given short shrift with the inquiries about Joao Cancelo, even if he will leave. City now regard Arsenal as a real threat.
It was not just in the way that Arsenal kept going, until their admittedly fortunate 101st minute equalising goal, but the celebrations that followed it and their ultimate penalty shoot-out victory.
The grin that spread across Arteta’s face as he climbed the Wembley steps betrayed the relief; even the sense of release. He was staring at a ninth successive defeat against Pep Guardiola’s City and whatever the occasion, whatever the preparedness of the teams, whether this was a glorified friendly or not, that would have hurt. That burden has gone. That block removed.
Arteta would have also faced questions that bring out his prickly side. Arsenal had spent more than £200million this summer – and started on Sunday with all three big-name signings in Declan Rice, Kai Havertz and Jurrien Timber – but they would have faced accusations they had choked again, that once more they could not go toe-to-toe with City. Even that there was an inferiority complex.
Such claims would have been harsh but would have hurt. A loss would have set them back for the forthcoming campaign in a way that defeat here, surely, does not affect City. But this time it was different.
Arsenal believe that. Aaron Ramsdale was unequivocal on what the view from the dressing room was. “For us, it’s a statement. It’s a marker to know we can go and beat Man City in a big game when it matters,” the goalkeeper said. “I’m not sure what it’ll be like this season. But that mental block has gone. We’re ready to push now.”
Such an admission of a “mental block” made Arteta bridle a little. Fair enough for the manager not to engage with that. But he did add: “It’s what the players feel and they are convinced they can beat any team.”
That shift in mentality was shown in the way Arsenal responded not once but twice. They had been blown away by City’s control in the opening 15 minutes. They could not get the ball. It was borderline embarrassing and such was City’s dominance that it looked like the rest of the Premier League should just pack up and go home.
But there was more about Arsenal. Thomas Partey was struggling but Rice was showing his competitiveness. They held firm, held their shape and came out of the first-half knowing that they should have, in fact, been in the lead. Instead Havertz wasted the two best chances, both superbly constructed, and so was that going to be the story? Was Arteta going to be accused of having spent so much money but leaving his team short of a recognised, instinctive goalscorer?
Erling Haaland did not have a shot before being substituted around the hour mark, in what looked like a planned change, and he may not have taken Havertz’s first chance. But he would have buried the second. He certainly would not have missed both.
So were Arsenal – again – open to the accusation of having a soft underbelly? Of not having that killer instinct? When Cole Palmer scored so sublimely it looked like he had exposed their fragility once more, sowing doubt into their season before it had barely begun.
City’s substitutions had worked. Palmer, Phil Foden and – inevitably – Kevin De Bruyne were running the show as Guardiola made three decisive changes before Arteta had even made one. Was it a sign that, once again, after the 7-2 aggregate pounding Arsenal suffered in losing twice to City in the Premier League last season, Arteta had been out-tacticked and dominated by his mentor, Guardiola and had failed to react decisively?
Instead he went for it. Arsenal played with three defenders and pushed City back. There was not an acceptance that they were inferior. Not this time. And Arteta celebrated the equalising goal far more wildly than Guardiola did in winning the Champions League not so long ago and completing that amazing Treble.
An over-reaction? Only time will tell. But for Arsenal it was big. If they had won the Community Shield against a different team it would not have been anywhere near as important even though it was the first trophy for Odegaard, the Arsenal captain, and only the second, after winning the FA Cup in 2020, for Arteta.
Is it even a trophy? Arteta’s reaction suggested it was while it was part of City’s “fourmidable” celebrations in 2019 when they won the four domestic trophies available. So they cannot have it both ways.
Only one of the last 12 Community Shield winners has gone on to be league champions. So this fixture has not proved to be a pointer in the past and only a fool would bet against Guardiola’s side. But Arsenal’s confidence is soaring. They will believe the shackles have been released. They will believe that the mental block has gone.