Review

Past Lives, review: this wondrous debut is the finest love story of the year

5/5

Roads not taken are at the heart of Celine Song’s shiver-inducing tale – sure to be a contender for Best Picture at next year’s Oscars

Teo Yoo as Hae Sung and Greta Lee as Nora in Past Lives
Teo Yoo as Hae Sung and Greta Lee as Nora in Past Lives Credit: Studiocanal

Nothing at the cinema this year has a hope of beating Past Lives for romantic delicacy, the cosmic yearning it puts into the three words, “I missed you.” It’s a wondrous, shiver-inducing film debut from the Canadian playwright Celine Song, who left Korea when she was 12. Deeply personal as her storytelling is here, it could unlock empathy from a bollard.

Two childhood sweethearts from Seoul, whom we meet in the late 1990s as they’re walking home from school, are reunited in adulthood, but they’ve been a world apart since Nora (Greta Lee) emigrated. She’s now married to a fellow writer in New York, Arthur (John Magaro), whom she met at an artists’ residence during one of two long periods when she and Hae-sung (Teo Yoo) lost touch. After changing her name, she’s been especially hard to track down, and only a coincidental Google of her old friend reconnects them.

The simplicity of the premise is quite disarming. On Hae-sung’s first ever visit, the conversations between these three speculate on kismet in ways that may remind you of Richard Linklater’s Before trilogy. Nora’s life, it’s clear, isn’t the only one etched irreversibly by her parents’ decision. 

How Arthur is placed – not as an obstacle, but an anxious third wheel – is deeply believable, and the language barrier crowds him out further, since Hae-sung’s minimal English (and Arthur’s minimal Korean) mean we alternate scenes in one language, then another.

Lee’s struggles for composure become as affecting as Yoo’s open vulnerability. They’re wonderful together, and Magaro’s wonderful on his own as Arthur, who gives them heroic latitude to catch up, and emerges as a figure so honest and crestfallen you can’t help but laugh. The trio are directed delicately enough by Song that their acting barely puts a foot wrong.

tmg.video.placeholder.alt kA244xewjcI

The film’s great magic is the way it captures the beauty of lonely cities with a camera that seems to caress their geography. (The cinematographer is the brilliant Shabier Kirchner, who shot Steve McQueen’s Small Axe.) A goodbye between the schoolchildren in Seoul’s foothills is unforgettable; so is Manhattan in and after rainfall. Even when no one’s speaking, the film has its eye on the roads not taken. 

The Statue of Liberty is more than a day-trip destination. She’s almost a villain: she may have beckoned Nora to the USA with dreams of a Nobel Prize, but to Hae-sung she presents a literal cold shoulder. When these two sit in front of a brightly revolving carousel in Brooklyn, every flicker on their faces is a question not asked out loud. The ending – a Carol-level knockout – makes it truly unmissable.


Past Lives is in cinemas on Sept 8